Cinematography and Technical Quality (All Categories)

All films will be judged based on the following criteria in the Cinematography and Technical Quality portion of every rubric.

Camera Work - Displays usage of various camera angles, good framing, smooth and steady movement, and good lighting.

Audio - Contains clear and easy to understand audio, balanced sound levels, and appropriate music and sound effects.

Pacing and Continuity - Contains appropriate pacing and maintains accurate continuity.

Effects, Images, & Titles - Uses effects and transitions effectively and appropriately and includes relevant images & titles.

Films will also be judged based on the following criteria in the Content and Impact portion of its category's rubric.

Animation (Content and Impact)

Story - Tells a compelling story with a clear, complete plot.

Originality - Tells an original story, displaying creativity and/or imagination through characters, scenarios, etc.

Characters - Contains relevant and well-developed characters.

Commercial (Content and Impact)

Purpose - Presents an explicit position on a clear product, concept, organization, cause, or perspective.

Originality - Makes an appeal through an original format, displaying creativity and/or imagination 

Persuasion - Attempts to persuade the audience through various techniques and favors those efforts over comedic efforts

Documentary (Content and Impact)

Purpose - Presents an explicit aspect of an event or person for presenting insight and displays a clear rationale.

Research - Features primary research into events or people beyond common knowledge.

Narration and Interviews - Displays clear evidence of narration rehearsal and balances narration and interviews effectively.

Music & Performing Arts (Content and Impact)

Story - Tells a compelling story with a clear, complete plot.

Originality - Tells an original story, displaying creativity and/or imagination.

Performance - Displays clear evidence of performance rehearsal and connection to the story.

Newscast (Content and Impact)

Content - Presents a variety of content in the broadcast that is relevant and appropriate for the intended audience.

Originality & Identity - Presents an original program, specifically tailored to represent and establish the school's identity.

Anchoring, Voiceovers, and Interviews - Displays evidence of anchor rehearsal; effectively utilizes voiceovers and interviews.

Short Films 3-12 and Teacher Only (Content and Impact)

Story - Tells a compelling story with a clear, complete plot.

Originality - Tells an original story, displaying creativity and/or imagination through characters, scenarios, etc.

Characters - Contains relevant and well-developed characters.

How-to K-2 Only (Content and Impact)

Purpose - Presents an explicit skill, project, or task for completion and establishes a rationale for the explanation.

Originality - Explains the skill through an original format, displaying creativity and/or imagination.

Process - Presents a logical process for the skill, project, or task with very clear instructions for completing each step.

Narration - Displays clear evidence of rehearsal.

All judging of films will be conducted by an outside third party, and the linked rubric below (based on the descriptions above) will be used to score each film. 

JUDGES RUBRIC